Graphene and carbon nanotubes (CNTs) are both forms of carbon with very high strength and conductivity, but their shapes differ: graphene is a flat sheet, while a nanotube is a sheet rolled into a cylinder. Flat sheets are well suited to barrier, thermal-spreading and surface effects, while long, thin tubes are well suited to forming conductive networks at low loading. The right choice depends on the property you need, how it disperses in your material and how you can handle it.
Both materials can disappoint if they are poorly dispersed, so the supply form matters as much as the carbon itself.
How do graphene and carbon nanotubes differ in structure?
Graphene is a single layer of carbon atoms in a hexagonal lattice; commercial graphene products usually contain few-layer sheets. Carbon nanotubes are the same lattice rolled into tubes, either single-walled or multi-walled. Graphene is two-dimensional, with a large flat surface. Nanotubes are one-dimensional, with a very high length-to-diameter ratio. Read what is graphene and graphene vs graphite for background.
Which is better for electrical conductivity?
Both can make insulating materials conductive once enough is added to form a connected network. Long nanotubes can bridge gaps at low loadings; graphene sheets can also form networks and offer broad contact areas. Real results depend on the grade, the dispersion quality and the host material. Our guide to conductive and antistatic graphene explains how to test it.
Which is better for barrier and protection?
Flat graphene sheets can lengthen the path that water, gases and corrosive species must travel through a coating or film, often called a tortuous-path or barrier effect. That is one reason graphene is studied in coatings and paints. Nanotubes are less suited to forming a barrier because of their shape.
Which is better for heat transfer?
Both have high thermal conductivity. Graphene's sheet shape suits heat spreading in coatings, polymers and fluids. Our ThermaGraph™ coolant is graphene in deionized water for closed-loop cooling, which showed +6% to +18% higher convective heat transfer coefficient than a glycol baseline in internal pumped-loop tests (internal testing results).
How do dispersion and handling compare?
Dry nanomaterial powders, whether graphene or nanotubes, tend to clump and can create dust. Many users find dispersion the hardest step. Graphene Integrations supplies graphene only pre-dispersed in water, solvents, resins or oils, so there is no dry graphene powder to handle. See graphene dispersions and dispersion stability.
How do I decide which to test?
- Name the property. Conductivity, barrier, strength, wear or heat transfer.
- Consider the host material. Water, solvent, resin, oil, cement or polymer melt.
- Check the supply form. Can you mix it uniformly with your equipment?
- Run a controlled trial against your current product. Our graphene additive trial guide explains how.
In some applications, formulators test both, or combinations, and let the data decide.
What results does Graphene Integrations publish?
We publish only results we can back with data, each tied to a specific product: +67.7% compressive strength at 5% by weight of cement in independent third-party testing (2023) for our concrete additive; up to 42% smaller four-ball wear-scar diameter and 26% higher weld load in independent lab testing for our lubricant additive, which is graphene integrated into oleic acid and monomer; and the ThermaGraph internal testing results above. See all case studies.
Frequently asked questions
Are carbon nanotubes rolled-up graphene?
Structurally, yes. A nanotube is a graphene lattice rolled into a cylinder, which gives it different properties from a flat sheet.
Does Graphene Integrations sell carbon nanotubes?
No. We manufacture graphene and supply it pre-dispersed in a carrier matched to your process.
Which is easier to disperse?
Both are difficult as dry powders. Buying a pre-dispersed product avoids most of the problem.
How much graphene should I add in a trial?
Most of our additives are dosed at 1% to 7% by weight, depending on the job. Concrete is validated at 5% by weight of cement.
Request a quote, samples or a spec sheet
Tell us your material, the property you want to improve, the carrier you use (water, solvent, resin or oil) and your volumes. Pricing and samples are by quote. Call 704-659-3682 or request a quote, samples or a spec sheet / SDS.
